V
VIN Check Engine

VEHICLE BUYER'S GUIDE

Tesla Model Y2020–2026

Year-by-year buyer intelligence from NHTSA safety data — reliability, value, and which years to target or avoid.

⚡ HYBRID
Tesla Model Y
2020–2026
D−
Defect Risk
Recall intensity
7.8/yr · seg. median 2.4
Safety
High
307 deaths · 578 inj.
Open Federal Investigation ×7
Engineering Analysis: electrical system
50% of EA investigations historically become recalls
60
Recalls
4,000
Complaints
2020
Best Yr
578
Injuries
Top issue: FORWARD COLLISION AVOIDANCE: ADAPTIVE CRUISE CONTROLAvoid 2022
7
Years Analyzed
60
Total Recalls
4000
Total Complaints
578
Reported Injuries
307
Reported Deaths

Best Years to Buy a Tesla Model Y

Buyer Score combines reliability (65%) and depreciation value (35%) — higher is better.

#1 PICK6yr old
2020
Acceptable · 48/100
Reliability35/100
Value window73/100
Recalls14
Complaints263
Top issue: FORWARD COLLISION AVOIDANCE: ADAPTIVE CRUISE CONTROL
#2 PICK1yr old
2025
Avoid · 41/100
Reliability41/100
Value window41/100
Recalls2
Complaints126
Top issue: UNKNOWN OR OTHER
#3 PICK2yr old
2024
Avoid · 39/100
Reliability31/100
Value window54/100
Recalls3
Complaints354
Top issue: FORWARD COLLISION AVOIDANCE: ADAPTIVE CRUISE CONTROL

Tesla Model Y Years to Avoid

#1 WORST
2022

12 recalls · 859 complaints

374 reported injuries

Top issue: FORWARD COLLISION AVOIDANCE: ADAPTIVE CRUISE CONTROL

#2 WORST
2023

10 recalls · 1079 complaints

63 reported injuries

Top issue: FORWARD COLLISION AVOIDANCE: ADAPTIVE CRUISE CONTROL

#3 WORST
2021

14 recalls · 951 complaints

27 reported injuries

Top issue: FORWARD COLLISION AVOIDANCE: ADAPTIVE CRUISE CONTROL

Federal Defect Investigations

NHTSA investigations are the stage that precedes a recall. 3 past investigations into the Model Y became recalls.

OPEN · EAEngineering Analysisopened Mar 2026NHTSA #EA26002
fsd collisions in reduced roadway visibility conditions
Component: electrical system:adas · affects 2020–2026
⚠ Historically, 50% of EA investigations became recalls — an in-depth Engineering Analysis — the most serious stage, just before a recall decision.
OPEN · PEPreliminary Evaluationopened Jul 2026NHTSA #PE26006
lower lateral link detachment
Component: suspension:front:control arm:lower arm · affects 2021–2023
⚠ Historically, 30% of PE investigations became recalls — a Preliminary Evaluation of a potential safety defect.
OPEN · PEPreliminary Evaluationopened Oct 2025NHTSA #PE25012
traffic safety violations while full self driving ("fsd") is engaged the office of defects
Component: electrical system:adas · affects 2020–2026
⚠ Historically, 30% of PE investigations became recalls — a Preliminary Evaluation of a potential safety defect.
OPEN · PEPreliminary Evaluationopened Sep 2025NHTSA #PE25010
electronic door handles become inoperative
Component: electrical system:12v/24v/48v battery · affects 2021
⚠ Historically, 30% of PE investigations became recalls — a Preliminary Evaluation of a potential safety defect.
OPEN · RQRecall Queryopened Apr 2024NHTSA #RQ24009
recall 23v838 remedy effectiveness
Component: electrical system:adas:driver monitoring:software · affects 2020–2024
⚠ Historically, 65% of RQ investigations became recalls — a Recall Query examining the scope or adequacy of a recall.
OPEN · DPDefect Petitionopened Jun 2023NHTSA #DP23002
sudden unintended acceleration
Component: vehicle speed control · affects 2019–2023
⚠ Historically, 2% of DP investigations became recalls — a Defect Petition review.
OPEN · AQAudit Queryopened Aug 2025NHTSA #AQ25002
compliance with standing general order 2021-01 reporting requirements
Component: electrical system:adas · affects 2020–2026
⚠ Historically, 3% of AQ investigations became recalls — an Audit Query into a recall's execution.
Recently concluded investigations
PE22002 · forward collision avoidance · closed Jun 2026Closed, no recall
EA24001 · steering · closed Jun 2026→ Became recall
PE23003 · steering · closed Apr 2026Closed, no recall
PE24033 · electrical system · closed Apr 2026Closed, no recall
PE24031 · electrical system · closed Mar 2026Closed, no recall
DP23001 · unknown or other · closed Mar 2026Closed, no recall
EA22002 · electrical system · closed Apr 2024→ Became recall
PE23014 · steering · closed Feb 2024Closed, no recall

Source: NHTSA Office of Defects Investigation. Data current as of October 28, 2026.

Tesla Model Y — Year-by-Year Comparison

Every model year ranked by Buyer Score. Click any year for its detailed problem report.

YearRecallsComplaintsInjuriesDeathsReliabilityValueBuyer ScoreVerdict
2026536823—
32
26
30
Good
2025212625—
41
41
41
Excellent
2024335438—
31
54
39
Good
202310107963—
16
64
33
Caution
202212859374304
16
71
35
Avoid
202114951273
16
74
36
Good
20201426328—
35
73
48
Good

Buyer Score = Reliability (65%) + Value window (35%). Deaths and injuries sourced from NHTSA complaint filings. Year links open full NHTSA problem reports.

Known Tesla Model Y Problems

Most frequently reported components across all model years, from NHTSA owner complaints.

FORWARD COLLISION AVOIDANCE: ADAPTIVE CRUISE CONTROL
642
FORWARD COLLISION AVOIDANCE: AUTOMATIC EMERGENCY BRAKING
526
UNKNOWN OR OTHER
349
SERVICE BRAKES
292
VEHICLE SPEED CONTROL
292
STEERING
250
ELECTRICAL SYSTEM
240
FORWARD COLLISION AVOIDANCE: WARNINGS
192

Complaint counts across all model years. Numbers indicate frequency, not severity.

Shopping by Era

How each generation of the Model Y compares — best year within each era shown.

2018–Present

Modern safety tech, refreshed platforms, updated powertrains. Higher purchase price but lower reliability risk. Best pick in this era: 2020 (Buyer Score 48).

Best: 2020
2020 · 482025 · 412024 · 392021 · 362022 · 352023 · 332026 · 30

Frequently Asked Questions

What is the best year Model Y to buy?+

The 2020 Tesla Model Y scores highest on our Buyer Score (48/100) — combining a reliability score of 35/100 with a value score of 73/100. It has 14 recalls and 263 NHTSA complaints on record.

Which Model Y years have the most problems?+

The 2022, 2023, 2021 model years have the highest problem scores in our analysis. The 2022 Model Y leads with 12 recalls and 859 owner complaints.

What is the Buyer Score?+

The Buyer Score is a composite metric that combines reliability (65% weight) and depreciation value (35% weight). Reliability reflects recall and complaint severity. Value reflects how much of the vehicle's depreciation has already been absorbed by prior owners — a 4–6 year old vehicle typically sits in the sweet spot.

What are the most common Model Y problems?+

The most frequently reported Tesla Model Y issues involve: FORWARD COLLISION AVOIDANCE: ADAPTIVE CRUISE CONTROL, FORWARD COLLISION AVOIDANCE: AUTOMATIC EMERGENCY BRAKING, UNKNOWN OR OTHER, SERVICE BRAKES. These are aggregated across all model years from NHTSA owner complaint filings. Frequency of complaints does not necessarily indicate severity.

Deep-Dive Research

Common Problems

Full year-by-year breakdown of every documented defect for the Tesla Model Y.

Reliability Score

Reliability rating and score breakdown compared to similar hybrid vehicles.

Years to Avoid

Every Model Y year ranked by problem score — worst years listed with full reasoning.

Found the right year? Verify the specific car.

A buyer's guide shows model-level risk. A VIN report shows the individual vehicle — accidents, odometer history, open recalls, and auction records.

Run a VIN Check →