HEAD-TO-HEAD COMPARISON
Honda Pilot vs Toyota Highlander
Honda Pilot
2003–2026 · suv
Toyota Highlander
2001–2026 · suv
Category-by-Category Breakdown
Every metric is normalized per model year so a long-running nameplate isn't unfairly penalized against a newer rival. The greener cell wins each row.
| Metric | Pilot | Highlander |
|---|---|---|
Defect & Recall Risk Higher is better | 43/100 | 56/100✓ |
Best Year Buyer Score Higher is better | 57/100 (2023) | 65/100 (2023)✓ |
Recalls per Year Lower is better | 3.1 | 2.5✓ |
Complaints per Year Lower is better | 349.4 | 145.7✓ |
Injuries + Deaths / Year Lower is better | 7✓ | 11.8 |
Crash-Involved Complaints Lower is better | 2.2%✓ | 8.4% |
| Categories won | 2 | 4 |
Best Year to Buy — Each Model
Most-Reported Problems
Complaint counts across all model years, from NHTSA owner filings. Frequency indicates how often an area is reported, not severity.
The Bottom Line
On the data, the Toyota Highlander is the safer used-car bet, winning 4 of 6 categories. It carries a 56/100 Reliability Index versus 43/100 for the Honda Pilot, and averages 2.5 recalls and 145.7 complaints per model year (vs 3.1 and 349.4). Whichever you choose, run the specific VIN — a single car's accident and title history can outweigh the model-level averages.
This compares models. A VIN report shows the individual vehicle — accidents, odometer history, open recalls, and auction records.