Ferrari 458 Italia Years to Avoid — Worst & Best Years to Buy

Q: What year 458 Italia should I avoid?

Based on NHTSA recall and complaint data, the 2010 Ferrari 458 Italia has the most documented problems with a problem score of 6 — driven by 2 recalls, 0 complaints.

Q: What is the best year 458 Italia to buy?

The 2012 Ferrari 458 Italia is the best-scoring year in our analysis with a problem score of only 3, meaning 1 recall and 0 complaints on record.

Q: Which 458 Italia has the fewest problems?

The 2012, 2013, 2015 model years have the fewest reported problems in the NHTSA database. Always verify a specific vehicle's history with a VIN report before purchasing.

Every Ferrari 458 Italia model year (2010–2015) ranked by recall count, complaint volume, deaths, and injuries. Data sourced directly from NHTSA.

Years Tracked

Total Recalls

Total Complaints

Reported Injuries

Reported Deaths

Ferrari 458 Italia Years to Avoid

#1 WORST

2010

2 recalls · 0 complaints

Top issue: No complaints on record

Problem score: 6

#2 WORST

2011

2 recalls · 0 complaints

Top issue: No complaints on record

Problem score: 6

#3 WORST

2014

2 recalls · 0 complaints

Top issue: No complaints on record

Problem score: 6

Best Ferrari 458 Italia Years to Buy

#1 BEST

2012

1 recall · 0 complaints

Main area: No significant complaints

Problem score: 3

#2 BEST

2013

1 recall · 0 complaints

Main area: No significant complaints

Problem score: 3

#3 BEST

2015

2 recalls · 0 complaints

Main area: No significant complaints

Problem score: 6

Found the right year? Verify that specific 458 Italia with a free VIN report.

Ferrari 458 Italia — Year-by-Year Problem Report

Year	Recalls	Injuries	Deaths	Problem Score	Verdict
2015	2	—	—	6	Avoid
2014	2	—	—	6	Avoid
2013	1	—	—	3	Caution
2012	1	—	—	3	Caution
2011	2	—	—	6	Avoid
2010	2	—	—	6	Avoid

All 6 model years shown. Deaths and injuries from NHTSA complaint filings. Higher problem scores indicate more reported safety issues.

Ferrari 458 Italia Shopping Guide by Era

2013–2017

Best: 2013

Mid-decade 458 Italia units are entering high-mileage territory. Inspect carefully for powertrain wear and verify recall completion status. The 2013 shows the lowest problem count for this era.

Pre-2013

Proceed with Caution

Older 458 Italia models have more accumulated wear and a larger recall history. These are higher-risk purchases without documented maintenance records and a clean VIN history report.

Frequently Asked Questions

What year 458 Italia should I avoid?+

Avoid the 2010 Ferrari 458 Italia if possible. It has 2 recalls, 0 owner complaints. The overall problem score is 6 — the highest in our dataset.

What is the best year 458 Italia to buy?+

The 2012 Ferrari 458 Italia is the lowest-risk year in our analysis, with a problem score of 3. It has only 1 recall and 0 complaints on record with NHTSA.

Which 458 Italia has the fewest problems?+

The 2012, 2013, 2015 model years have the fewest documented problems. Even for low-problem years, verifying a specific vehicle's history via its VIN is always recommended before purchase.

More Ferrari 458 Italia Research

Reliability Score

Overall reliability rating and score breakdown for the Ferrari 458 Italia.

Common Problems

Full breakdown of every reported defect for the Ferrari 458 Italia.

Check a Specific Ferrari 458 Italia VIN

Model-year rankings show statistical risk. A VIN-specific report reveals the individual vehicle's full history — accidents, odometer rollbacks, auction records, and open recall status.

Run a Free VIN Report →